One of the most embarrassing moments of my life happened early in my career (circa 2009) when I rushed into a radio production meeting with what I thought was an incredible breaking news story, only to be reminded upon pitching it that it was April the 1st, and maybe I should check my facts.
In my limited defence, this was a time when even legitimate news organisations would run April Fool’s Day pranks on their websites (some still do, others who value their credibility have sensibly stopped). Journalists who have a reputation for truth and facts are finding out it’s best to avoid blurring the lines – even on social media.
No longer creating their own April Fool’s content, news organisations then had to be wary of falling for the traps set by others – reporting a prank as actual news. That was the snare I almost fell into, and others have not been so fortunate. It became a minefield for news organisations, particularly as the 24-hour and online news cycles became dominant.
Today, April Fool’s Day has become primarily the domain of brands and corporate social media teams, eagerly preparing this year’s excellent prank (excellence not guaranteed). But it comes with significant risk. Many pranks have gone dramatically awry, as Mike Snider details in USA Today.
Nonetheless, companies still see April Fool’s Day on the calendar and think “oh, there’s a good opportunity for content” without considering the skill it takes to pull off a good prank and the possible flow-on effects to their brand.
In 2021, Chaim Gartenberg argued (accurately) that an April Fool’s Day post was almost always a bad idea. When the pandemic occurred, most companies shelved the annual April Fool’s Day prank, correctly assessing that it was not the time. Gartenberg says it should have stayed on the shelf.
Let this be the year April Fools’ Day for brands dies – The Verge
(Narrator: It did not stay on the shelf)
April Fool’s Day posts can create engagement, so that’s good. But they can also create frustration and erode trust if handled poorly. That’s really bad. Is the risk worth the reward?
So next year, if you’re thinking about an April Fool’s Day social media post for your business, ask yourself the following three questions:
1- Is this funny? (Ask someone outside the company for their honest opinion. If they don’t think it’s funny, don’t do it)
2- Will people take this seriously? (If so, don’t do it)
3 – Is your brand the sort to do an April Fool’s prank? Is this an established element of your voice (if not, don’t do it)
Maybe just don’t do it.